What Are the Pros and Cons of Joining a Nursing Union?
NurseJournal.org is committed to delivering content that is objective and actionable. To that end, we have built a network of industry professionals across higher education to review our content and ensure we are providing the most helpful information to our readers.
Drawing on their firsthand industry expertise, our Integrity Network members serve as an additional step in our editing process, helping us confirm our content is accurate and up to date. These contributors:
- Suggest changes to inaccurate or misleading information.
- Provide specific, corrective feedback.
- Identify critical information that writers may have missed.
Integrity Network members typically work full time in their industry profession and review content for NurseJournal.org as a side project. All Integrity Network members are paid members of the Red Ventures Education Integrity Network.
- Nursing Union Pros and Cons: At a Glance
- What Is a Nursing Union?
- Nursing Union Pros
- Nursing Union Cons
- Nursing Union Frequently Asked Questions
- Nursing Union Resources
Are you ready to earn your online nursing degree?
Credit: PeopleImages / E+ / Getty ImagesLabor unions give workers the power to negotiate for better working conditions, and nurses’ unions are no different. Many nurses join a union to advocate for better hours, increased pay, and positive changes in the workplace. While there are many advantages to joining a nurses’ union, there are also drawbacks to consider.
This guide explores the pros and cons of joining a nursing union, along with some frequently asked questions.
Nurses’ Union Pros and Cons: At a Glance
Pros
Ensure safe working conditions- Advocate for better pay
- Ensure due process for discipline
- Provide consistent standards for hiring, promotion, and termination
- Investigates grievances
Cons
Union fees- Unpaid strikes
- Not all members support all collective action
- Seniority more rewarded than performance
- Can protect nurses over patients
What Is a Nurses’ Union?
Nurses’ unions are unified organizations that represent a specific group of nurses, such as those who work in a certain hospital system or a particular state. Unions advocate for nurses and protect their rights through collective action and negotiations.
Nurses’ Union Pros
Members can expect a nurses’ union to do the following.
Ensure Safe Working Conditions
Nurses’ unions mandate certain standards for working conditions, including staffing levels, adequate breaks, safety equipment, and protection from violence and harassment.
Advocate for Better Pay
Nurses advocate for better pay and benefits. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, healthcare workers (not just nurses) who are union members earn an average of $1,380 weekly, compared to $1,200 for those who are not in or represented by a union.
Some unions also provide added benefits, like paying for health insurance premiums.
Unions also ensure bonuses and yearly or biyearly raises are built into contracts. Unions and a collective bargaining unit will help to ensure those yearly benchmarks are met and raises are given.
Ensure Due Process for Discipline
Nurses’ unions establish processes for nurses facing disciplinary charges. These guidelines ensure that nurses cannot be terminated or disciplined unfairly or inconsistently.
Provide Consistent Standards for Hiring, Promotion, and Termination
Nurses’ unions verify that the same rules apply to hiring, promotion, and termination. This means that employees know what to expect and that everyone is held to the same standards.
Investigate Grievances
Nurses who raise a complaint with management do not have to do so on their own. They can call for the nurses’ union to investigate and act for them if they have cause for complaint. Some unions will supply an attorney rather than the nurse having to find their own attorney.
While these actions provide nurses with valuable support, there can be downsides to nurses’ unions.
Nurses’ Union Cons
There are also some reasons not to join or support a nurses’ union or its policies.
Union Fees
While most unions get more pay for their members than they cost the nurses in fees, union fees are still an item out of your paycheck.
Unpaid Strikes
Strikes are a union’s most powerful action, but they carry a cost. Striking nurses aren’t paid, and some nurses may not personally support the cause behind a strike.
Not All Members Support All Collective Action
While unions derive their power from collective action, some members might not always support all union stances. For example, many nurses support vaccination mandates for healthcare professionals, while some nurses’ unions oppose them.
Seniority More Rewarded Than Performance
According to many nursing union contracts, promotions and/or raises are based on seniority. The person who has worked the longest gets the first chance at a promotion or a larger raise. Many hospitals and unions will also have an advancement ladder that factors education, certifications, and years of experience.
Seniority is objective and easy to measure. However, when seniority is the most important factor in promotions, stellar performers receive the same rewards as those who are only adequate workers.
Can Protect Nurses Over Patients
Unions are designed to protect nurses rather than patients, which can negatively impact patient care. For example, unions make it difficult to terminate nurses, which may empower nurses who perform poorly.
Nurses’ Union FAQs
Some questions may arise as you consider the pros and cons of nursing unions. Here are a few frequently asked questions.
Are nursing unions good or bad?
Nursing unions protect indispensable members of the healthcare industry. Many union policies and developments, such as adequate staffing ratios and safety equipment, directly help patients. Some research indicates nurses’ union membership results in better patient outcomes. However, unions’ emphasis on standards and seniority may remove some motivation for excellent performance.
Do unions benefit or harm healthcare and nursing industries?
The pros and cons of unions in healthcare often spark debate. While unions protect and advocate for workers, they represent only one part of the healthcare ecosystem. Unions may fight for their members at the expense of patients and other stakeholders.
Should I join a nurses’ union? What are the pros and cons?
The pros and cons of nursing unions depend on your personal choices and priorities. Before joining, you should consider factors like dues, the likelihood of going on strike, the union’s leadership and ethics, and your career goals.
What is the purpose of a nursing union?
A nursing union protects and advocates for nurses, using collective action to make demands on members’ behalf. These demands often involve compensation, working conditions, and work policies and procedures.
Many hospitals work hard to get the American Nurses Credentialing Center’s Magnet designation. Staffing, pay levels, and nursing education are all aspects nursing unions help with, so there can be overlay between union requirements and Magnet status.
Nurses’ Union Resources
These resources offer more information on nurses’ unions, so you can decide if the pros of joining outweigh the cons.
National Nurses United
With approximately 175,000 members, NNU is the nation’s largest nurses’ union.National Union of Healthcare Workers
NUHW supports around 15,000 members from all healthcare fields.National Labor Relations Board
This federal agency enforces labor laws, including those regulating unions.For Health Care Workers, The Pandemic Is Fueling Renewed Interest In Unions
This NPR story explores COVID-19’s impact on unions and union membership.The History of Unions in the United States
Investopedia provides a broad historical overview of unions, including a look at current efforts.
Related Reading
Reviewed by:
Elizabeth Clarke (Poon) is a board-certified family nurse practitioner who provides primary and urgent care to pediatric populations. She earned a BSN and MSN from the University of Miami.
Clarke is a paid member of our Healthcare Review Partner Network. Learn more about our review partners.
